She Was Mending Fences at Dawn When the Cowboy Rode Over and Said He Could Not Stop Thinking
…
He pulled up about 10 feet from where she was standing.
And he sat there for a moment with his hands resting easy on the saddle horn.
Looking at her, and then at the broken fence, and then back at her.
“Morning,” he said, and his voice was the kind of low and unhurried that you do not perform.
It was simply how he spoke.
“Morning,” she replied, not setting down her hammer.
“I am riding through from the Larson place,” he said, “cutting across your north parcel if that is all right.
Your fence was already down when I came through.
” “I know it was already down,” she said.
“I am mending it right now.
” He tilted his head very slightly, and she thought she saw something move across his expression, though it was too quick to catalog.
He swung down from the dun in a single smooth motion and dropped the reins, and the horse stood still without being tied, which told her something.
“You need another set of hands,” he said.
It was not a question.
“I am managing fine.
” “You are,” he agreed, and he said it in a way that was not condescending, just honest.
But, two people will finish it in half the time, and I do not have anywhere urgent to be this morning.
” Clara studied him for a moment.
In 1882, a woman running a ranch alone was not unheard of, but it was never entirely comfortable either.
And a strange man offering help was something you measured carefully before you accepted it.
She looked at his hands.
They were working hands, calloused and scarred in the particular way of men who did real labor.
She looked at his horse, which was well kept and not nervous.
She looked at his eyes, which were patient and did not move to places they had no business moving.
“There is a spare hammer in the saddlebag on my horse,” she said.
Which was as close to yes as she was going to get on first meeting.
He walked to where her mare was tied at the gate post and found the hammer without going through anything else in the bag, which she noticed.
He came back and knelt beside the broken post she had not yet addressed and began working without another word.
And something about that about the way he simply began rather than waiting for instructions or offering opinions settled something in her chest.
They worked in silence for a while.
The sun climbed.
Frost burned off the grass and the meadowlarks started up in the willows along the creek.
Clara reset the rails on her side, and he set them on his, and they met in the middle at the fourth post and worked together to get the cross bracing in, and their hands were close but did not touch.
“I am Clara Dawson,” she said when they stepped back to check the line.
“Eli Crane,” he said, and he offered his hand in the same direct way you would to another man without ceremony or condescension, and she shook it.
“Are you working the Larson spread?” she asked.
“Temporarily,” he said.
“Pete Larson hired me on for the fall roundup and asked me to stay through winter to help with the herd.
I am riding out to check the upper pasture this morning.
” “I know Pete,” she said.
“Good man.
” “He is,” Eli agreed.
They walked the rest of the fence line together, checking for other damage, and Clara was aware of being surprised by how natural it felt to walk beside someone through her own land.
She had been alone on the Dawson place for 2 years since her father had died of a fever that swept through the territory in the winter of 1880.
And before that, she had run the ranch alongside him since she was old enough to be useful, which was young.
She had never married, though not for lack of opportunity.
There had been offers.
She had turned them all down because she had the distinct feeling each time that what was being offered was not really a partnership, but a transaction, and she was not interested in being a transaction.
“You did this yourself?” Eli asked, gesturing broadly at the property, at the barn with its new siding, the garden beds turned and mounded for winter, the orderly stack of firewood against the south wall of the house.
“My father and I built most of it,” she said.
“I have kept it up since he passed.
” He nodded slowly.
And the respect in that nod was not the kind that was put on for politeness.
It was the kind that came from understanding how much work the thing you were looking at actually represented.
“I am sorry about your father,” he said.
“Thank you,” she said, and she meant it in a way that she did not often mean those words.
Because he said it simply and did not follow it with any of the usual platitudes that people added when they felt uncomfortable with grief.
By the time they had walked the full northern line and confirmed that only the three sections needed major work, the sun was well up, and Clara’s stomach was reminding her that she had not eaten.
She was considering whether it would be appropriate to offer him coffee when he stopped walking and turned to face the mountains.
“I have been riding through this territory for 3 years,” he said.
Not as a statement directed at her so much as a thought he had apparently decided to speak aloud.
“I have covered Kansas and Colorado and most of Wyoming.
I have seen country that would take your breath clean away.
” He paused.
“But, there is something about this particular morning that I am going to remember.
” Clara looked at him from the side, not quite directly.
The light was full gold now, and it lay across his profile and across the mountains behind him and across the whole wide morning.
And she thought that it was a strange thing for a man to say, and also that it was exactly right.
“Coffee,” she said, because she did not know what else to offer in response to something like that.
And also because she genuinely wanted it.
If you have time before you ride out.
” He turned and looked at her, and the corner of his mouth moved in a way that was not quite a smile, but was the beginning of one.
“I have time,” he said.
The kitchen of the Dawson house was small and warm.
With a cast iron stove that Clara kept going through all of October and did not let die until April.
The walls were hung with her mother’s quilts, the colors faded to a pleasant softness, and the table was solid pine scarred with years of use.
Eli sat in the chair across from her without being told to.
Not awkwardly.
But, with the ease of someone who understood how to be in a space without taking it over.
She set the coffee on and cut two slices of the bread she had made the night before and put them on the table with butter.
And a small jar of the plum preserves she had put up in August.
“This is good bread,” he said after the first bite, and the way he said it as though the observation genuinely pleased him, made her want to smile in spite of herself.
“My mother’s recipe,” she said.
“She was from Ohio.
She said Wyoming flour behaved differently than Ohio flour, but she was always saying things like that.
She had a theory about the altitude.
” “Was she right? Probably.
She was right about most things.
” “Is she gone, too? When I was 12,” Clara said, “fever, also.
” It was a bad winter.
He was quiet for a moment, and she liked that he did not rush to fill the silence.
Most people did when you mentioned something sad, as though silence after sorrow was a hole that needed plugging.
Eli let it sit, and somehow that gave it its proper weight.
“Your family built something real here,” he said eventually.
“We did,” she said, “and I intend to keep it.
” Something shifted in his expression at that, a recognition of something, and he looked at her with a directness that was not rude, but was very deliberate.
“I believe you,” he said.
Eli rode out an hour after the sun had fully cleared the mountains, heading up toward the Larson upper pasture, as he had originally intended.
Clara stood at the fence gate and watched him go, and she told herself that what she was feeling was simply the particular gratitude of someone who had received unexpected help on a hard morning.
She stood there longer than she needed to, watching the dun horse and its rider move across the golden grass until they became small, and then disappeared over the ridge.
She went back to work.
The days that followed were ordinary in the way that ranch days were ordinary, which was to say that they were full from before dawn until after dark, and left no room for brooding.
Clara fixed the remaining damage to the barn siding.
She mucked the stalls and turned the horses out into the pasture for their afternoon run.
She saddled her mare and rode the property line to check for signs of that troublesome steer, found his tracks along the south creek, and spent the better part of an afternoon running him back into the herd.
She repaired a leak in the roof of the root cellar.
She baked and preserved and mended, and logged her accounts by lamplight each evening.
But in the margins of those days, in the walk between the barn and the house at twilight, in the quiet moment before sleep, she found herself thinking about Eli Crane.
It irritated her, because she was a practical woman, and she had no patience for her own impracticality.
She had spoken to the man for perhaps 2 hours total.
She knew almost nothing about him, except that he worked for Pete Larson, that he rode a dun horse well, that he did not talk merely to fill space, and that when he said something, it tended to mean something.
That was not very much to go on, and yet she kept returning to the particular quality of his attention, the way he had looked at her while she worked, not with appraisal, not with the measuring look she was accustomed to from men who were calculating what a woman alone on a good piece of land might be worth, but with something closer to recognition, as though he saw what she actually was.
She was being foolish, she told herself.
She did not know this man, but she thought about him just the same.
It was 11 days after their morning at the fence, when she rode into the town of Clearwater on her monthly supply run.
Clearwater was a proper town by 1882 Wyoming standards, with a general store, a post office, a church, a doctor’s office, a livery, a saloon, and a hotel that had aspirations.
Clara tied her mare at the post outside the general store and went in to give Hector Bowman her supply list.
The store was busy, which was unusual for a Tuesday morning in late October, and she understood why when she heard the voices in the back.
Pete Larson was there, leaning against the counter, and beside him stood Eli Crane.
She registered the small, involuntary lift of her own heart with the same mix of pleasure and exasperation she had been experiencing for 11 days.
Pete saw her first.
“Clara Dawson,” he said warmly.
Pete Larson was 50, red-faced, good-humored, and had been her father’s friend.
He crossed the store and took her hand in both of his.
“Good to see you, girl.
I have been meaning to ride over and check on you since that north wind came through.
” “I am fine, Pete.
Thank you,” she said.
“The fence took some damage, but it is all mended.
” “Eli here told me he helped you with it,” Pete said, and there was something careful in his voice, something that suggested he had noticed more in Eli’s telling of that morning than the simple fact of fence mending.
She looked at Eli then, because there was no longer a reasonable way not to.
He was standing perhaps 8 feet away, and he was looking at her with an expression that she could only describe as careful and also warm, which was a combination she had not thought possible before.
“It was kind of him to help,” she said.
“Morning, Miss Dawson,” Eli said.
“Mr. Crane,” she said.
Pete looked between them with the conspicuous innocence of a man who was trying very hard not to look conspicuous.
They ended up walking out of the store at the same time, which happened naturally and without arrangement, and then they were standing on the wooden sidewalk in the thin autumn sunlight, and the street of Clearwater moved around them, horses and wagons and the distant voices from the saloon down the road.
“How is the upper pasture?” she asked, because it was a neutral and sensible thing to ask.
“Good,” he said.
“The creek is running clean, plenty of grass left before the freeze.
” “That is good country up there,” she said.
“My father used to summer the herd on the upper Larson lease in exchange for water rights, before Pete bought the land, that is.
” “He mentioned that,” Eli said.
“He said your father was a fair man to do business with.
” “He was,” she said.
She noticed that she did not feel the grief of it as a sharp thing when she talked to Eli, but rather as a settled thing, a weight that had been properly placed.
They were quiet for a moment on the sidewalk, and the awkward thing that was supposed to happen in such a pause did not happen.
Instead, the quiet between them was the kind that two people share when they are comfortable, and also when there is something unspoken that both of them are aware of.
“I have been thinking,” Eli said, and he stopped there for a moment as though choosing his next words very deliberately, “about that morning, at the fence.
” “As have I,” she said before she could decide whether to say it or not.
He looked at her with an expression that was startled and also pleased.
“I am not a man who says things he does not mean,” he said.
“So, I want to be careful and clear.
I’m not a man with a great deal to offer right now.
I am working for wages on another man’s land.
I have a horse, a saddle, and a fair knowledge of cattle.
That is the sum of it.
” “I did not ask you to offer me anything,” she said, meeting his eyes directly.
“No,” he said.
“You did not, but I wanted to say it before I said the other thing.
” “And what is the other thing?” she asked, and her voice was steady, which she was grateful for.
“That I have not been able to stop thinking about that morning,” he said.
“About you, the way you were working, the way you spoke, the way you were with your land.
” He paused.
“I have ridden through a great many places, and I have met a great many people, and I do not generally find myself thinking about them the way I have been thinking about you.
” The street noise continued around them.
A wagon rolled by.
Someone called a greeting from across the road.
The world went about its business while Clara Dawson stood on the sidewalk in Clearwater, Wyoming, and decided what to do with the most honest thing a man had said to her in recent memory.
“I am not a woman who is easy to know,” she said.
“I have been told that.
” “I expect the person who said it found easy knowing to be the goal,” he said.
“I do not.
” She considered this, then she said, “There is a church supper on Friday.
The whole town goes.
It is perfectly respectable, and the food is very good, because Mr.s.
Abernathy makes her apple cake.
” He looked at her with that almost smile again.
“Is that an invitation?” “It is me telling you about a community event,” she said.
“What you do with the information is your own business.
” He was smiling fully now, and it transformed his face into something that Clara noted, with great internal composure, was remarkably fine.
“I will see if I can arrange to be in town on Friday,” he said.
“That would be your own decision,” she said, and turned to go untie her horse, and she felt his eyes on her as she did, and she was glad that her back was to him, so he could not see that she was smiling.
The church supper on Friday was held in the meeting hall attached to the small, whitewashed church on the east end of Clearwater’s main street.
Clara arrived in the buckboard with a pot of beans she had been cooking since morning.
She wore her good dress, which was dark blue wool, and she had braided her hair up in a way that she had not bothered with since last Christmas.
Eli was already there when she arrived, which she had not expected, and for a moment she stood at the door of the hall with her pot of beans and watched him without him seeing her.
He was talking to Pete Larson and to Reverend Holt, the young minister who had come out from Ohio 3 years prior, and had never managed to quite shed the look of a man still adjusting to the size of the western sky.
Eli’s hat was off, which she had not seen before.
His dark hair was combed.
He had traded his work coat for a cleaner one.
He was nodding at something the reverend said, and even from across the room she could see that his attention was full and genuine.
He turned then as people sometimes do when someone is watching them and found her at the door.
The expression that crossed his face when he saw her was so unguarded that it nearly made her look away.
He excused himself from Pete and the reverend and came across the room and took the pot of beans from her hands without ceremony.
“Heavy.
” He said.
“I cooked for 20.
” She said.
“There will be 20.
” “There will be 32.
” He said.
“I counted the tables.
” “Then it is a good thing I cooked extra.
” They ate at one of the long wooden tables surrounded by the noise and warmth of the community.
And Clara was aware of the look she was receiving from various neighbors.
The particular kind of communal curiosity that a small western town applies to any new combination of people.
She was aware of it, and she did not find that she minded it as much as she might have expected to.
Eli was good with people in the way that she had sensed he might be.
Not loud about it.
Not charming in a performative way, but genuinely interested in what people had to say.
He asked Pete’s wife about her garden.
He listened to old Hector Bowman’s rambling story about the buffalo hunt of 1869 without letting his eyes drift.
When the reverend’s wife cornered him about volunteering for the spring fence mending project, he said yes without being maneuvered into it.
After supper, when the tables were cleared and someone produced a fiddle, and the hall rearranged itself for dancing, Eli came to where Clara was standing near the windows and held out his hand.
“I should warn you.
” He said.
“I am not a graceful dancer.
” “I should warn you.
” She said, taking his hand, “that I do not care.
” He was not a graceful dancer.
He was honest about that.
He moved with more determination than elegance, counting under his breath in a way that she found endearing rather than embarrassing.
But his hand on her waist was warm and steady, and he kept his eyes on her face rather than on his feet, which she thought was the right choice of the two.
They danced three times, and after the third dance they stepped out onto the church steps to let the cool night air in.
And the stars were extraordinary the way Wyoming stars are in late October, clear and close and innumerable.
“Tell me something about yourself.
” She said.
“Something true.
” He leaned his elbows on the porch railing and was quiet for a moment, which she appreciated because it meant he was actually thinking about it.
“I grew up in Missouri.
” He said.
“My father farmed corn.
I worked the farm until I was 19, and then I came west because I felt like if I did not go I would spend my entire life in the same 12 square miles, and I was afraid that would make me into something small.
” He paused.
“I’m not sure now if that makes me brave or selfish.
” “I left my mother with a lot of the farm work when I went.
” “Did you send money home?” “Every month for 6 years until she sold the farm and went to live with my sister in St.
Louis.
” “Then it was not selfish.
” She said.
“It was complicated.
” He said.
“I think most things a person does are.
” “Yes.
” She said.
“I think so, too.
” “What about you?” He asked.
“Tell me something true.
” She thought about it.
“I’m afraid of losing this land.
” She said.
“Not in a general way, but in a very specific way.
I have had two offers to buy the property in the last year from the same man, Marcus Webb, who owns the cattle operation on the western side of the valley.
He wants the water rights to the creek that runs through my north pasture.
He has been persistent, and he has made it clear in a number of ways that he thinks a woman alone on 40 acres is a temporary situation.
” She paused.
“And sometimes I am afraid he is right.
Not because I am incapable, but because the world is arranged in such a way that capable does not always count for enough.
” Eli was quiet for a long moment after that.
Then he said, “He is not right.
” “You cannot know that.
” She said.
“No.
” He said.
“But I know you well enough already to know that it would take something extraordinary to move you off land that you care about the way you care about that place.
” She looked at him in the starlight, and something in her chest loosened very slightly.
A tension she had been holding so long she had stopped being aware of it.
“We have known each other 11 days.
” She said.
“12.
” He said.
“And sometimes you know a thing in 12 days that other people take 12 years to get around to.
” She could not argue with that because she was thinking the same thing and had been for most of those 12 days.
November came in hard and cold with the first real snow on the fifth and a hard freeze a week after.
Clara brought the cattle into the lower pasture and increased the feed.
She checked the horses twice a day for ice in their water.
She banked the wood pile higher and reinforced the weather stripping on the kitchen door.
Eli Crane came over on the first Sunday after the snow, riding the dun through 6 inches of fresh powder.
And when she came to the door, he was holding a small bundle of firewood under one arm and had a slightly uncertain expression on his face, as though he was not entirely sure of his welcome, but had come anyway.
She opened the door wider and said, “Wipe your boots.
” He became, over the following weeks, a fixture of her Sundays and eventually of her Wednesday evenings as well.
When he would ride over from the Larson place after his work was done and sit with her in the kitchen while she did her accounts, and they talked about everything that occurred to them.
They talked about the cattle market, which was shifting with the expansion of the railroads.
They talked about the territory’s push towards statehood, which was generating considerable argument among the ranchers over land rights and grazing regulations.
They talked about books because Clara had a shelf of them that she guarded fiercely.
And Eli turned out to have read more widely than she had expected, having carried whatever he could find with him across the territory.
He told her about the places he had seen.
The Red River country of Texas.
The Bear High Desert of New Mexico.
The first time he had ridden into Colorado and felt the full weight of the Rockies pressing down on him like a physical thing.
She told him about the summer her father had taken her on a cattle drive at 14.
How she had ridden for 10 days beside real drovers who had not known what to make of her.
How she had earned their grudging respect by the third day and their genuine respect by the seventh.
She told him about her mother, which she did not often do.
How she had taught Clara to read by lamplight when Clara was four.
How she had made the best dried apple pie in all of Laramie County and had been modest about it in a way that drove other women slightly mad.
How she had come west as a bride of 19 and had never once looked back at Ohio with anything except mild nostalgia.
“She would have had a great deal of opinions about you.
” Clara said one evening.
Eli looked up from the almanac he had been examining.
“Good opinions.
” “She was a practical woman.
” Clara said.
“She had opinions.
Whether they were good would have depended entirely on what you said next.
” “What would I have needed to say?” Clara considered.
“She used to say that the one question worth asking a man was what he was building toward.
” She said.
“Not what he had done.
Not where he had been.
She said the past was settled and could not be changed, and the only thing that told you anything useful about a person was what they were moving toward.
” Eli set the almanac down and looked at her directly with his hands flat on the table.
“And what would you say?” He asked.
“If I were to tell you what I am building toward?” Her heart was very still in her chest, a peculiar stillness that was also very loud.
“I would say that I am listening.
” She said.
“I want land.
” He said.
“My own land.
” “I have been working for wages since I came west because you cannot buy land with nothing, and I started with nothing.
I have saved enough now for a modest piece, not 40 acres, but a start.
I want a place that I am working for myself, not for another man’s count.
” He paused.
“And I want to not be doing it alone.
That is a thing I have been aware of for a long time, but I have been more aware of it since October.
” “Since October?” She said.
“Since a morning at the end of October.
” He said.
“When I came across a woman mending fence at dawn who seemed entirely self-sufficient and entirely worth knowing.
” The lamp between them threw warm light across the table, across his hands, across the pine walls in her mother’s quilts.
Outside the wind pushed at the house and the snow creaked under its own weight on the roof, and the whole of it was so much the thing that Clara had built and loved and feared losing that she felt it like a physical sensation in her throat.
“I am very self-sufficient.
” She said.
“I know.
” He said.
“That is not why I want to help.
” “Then why?” “Because I want to.
” He said.
“Not because you need me to.
Because I want to be in the same place as you.
That is the whole of it.
” She stood up and went to the stove and refilled the coffee pot with water from the pump, and she stood there for a moment with her back to him, and she let the feeling have its full measure before she turned around.
“It is cold to be riding back to the Larson place tonight,” she said.
“It is,” he agreed.
“The barn has a good loft,” she said.
“There is clean hay and a blanket.
You are welcome to it if you would rather ride back in the morning light.
” He looked at her, and she met his eyes, and there was an understanding between them that was entirely clear and entirely proper.
Which was to say that the loft was the loft and the house was the house, and she was not suggesting anything except practical shelter from a cold night.
“I appreciate the offer,” he said, and the warmth in his voice was for the offer itself, and also for everything that the offer represented, which was trust.
The problem with Marcus Webb became concrete in December.
Clara was coming out of the post office on a Thursday afternoon when she nearly walked directly into him.
Webb was a big man, not tall exactly, but wide in the way of men who had been strong and were now going soft around the edges.
And he had a way of standing in the center of any available space that she had always found aggressive.
He was flanked by a man she did not know, a thin, pale-eyed man who wore a gun very deliberately.
“Miss Dawson,” Webb said, with the particular pleasantry of a man who is not being pleasant.
“Mr. Webb,” she said, moving to step around him.
“I was hoping to talk with you,” he said, shifting his own weight to block her path in a way that was subtle enough to be deniable.
“About the property.
” “My answer remains the same as the last two times,” she said.
“The price I am offering is more than fair for 40 acres,” he said, “given the condition of things.
” “The condition of things is excellent,” she said.
“The fence has been freshly mended, the barn is sound, and the herd is healthy.
Thank you for your concern.
” Webb’s expression shifted very slightly, and the pleasantness went out of it, replaced by something flatter.
“A woman alone through a Wyoming winter,” he said.
“Things can happen.
Fences come down.
Cattle drift.
It would be a shame to be caught unprepared.
” She held his gaze steadily.
“I am never unprepared, Mr. Webb,” she said.
“And I would suggest being careful about the implications of what you just said.
” She walked around him and did not look back.
She told Eli about it that Sunday, and she watched his expression go very quiet and very still in the way that she was beginning to understand meant he was thinking carefully about something that he felt strongly.
“He is threatening you,” Eli said.
“He is implying,” she said.
“It is a distinction he is very careful about.
” “It is not a distinction that matters,” he said.
“The meaning is clear.
” “Yes,” she said.
“It is.
” “I have reported it to Sheriff Aldrin for what that is worth.
” “What did Aldrin say?” “He said that Marcus Webb was a substantial contributor to the economic health of the valley, and that there was nothing he could do about implications.
” She said it without bitterness, just factually, because this too was a truth of 1882 Wyoming that she had no energy for pretending around.
Eli was quiet again.
Then he said, “I want to ride your fence line with you tomorrow, if you will let me.
And I want to know every section of your property boundary, because if anything happens to any of it, I want to know it is not a natural accident.
” She looked at him.
“You have work at the Larson place.
” “Pete will understand,” he said.
“And I already spoke to him about the possibility.
” “You spoke to Pete about Webb.
” “I mentioned to Pete that I had some concerns about your situation,” he said.
“Pete knows Webb.
He has had his own difficulties with the man.
” She felt something that was gratitude and also something more complicated, the feeling of not being alone with a problem, which was both a relief and also deeply unfamiliar.
“All right,” she said.
“Tomorrow morning.
” They rode the full perimeter of the Dawson property the next day in the cold, bright December air.
And Eli made notes in a small notebook he carried in his coat pocket, recording landmarks and condition, and anything that could be used as documentation if a dispute arose.
He treated it with the seriousness of a man who understood that land and the legal claims upon it were matters of real consequence, which they were.
It was during that ride, crossing the north pasture with the mountains enormous to the west, that he said simply and without prologue, “I have spoken to Pete about buying a parcel from him on the eastern edge of his property, about 20 acres.
He is willing to sell at a fair price.
” She reined in her horse and looked at him.
“The eastern edge borders your north pasture,” she said.
“It does,” he said.
“That was not an accident.
” She let her mare walk on slowly, thinking.
“You would be a neighbor,” she said.
“I would be,” he said.
“And eventually, if you were willing, I was thinking of something more formal than that.
” She looked at him fully then, and the mountains were behind him, and the sky was winter pale and enormous, and his face was open and honest and waiting.
“Eli Crane,” she said.
“If you are asking what I think you are asking, then you ought to do it properly.
” He reached across the space between their horses and took her gloved hand in his.
“Clara Dawson,” he said.
“I came west to find something I could not name when I was 19, and I have found it.
And it is not land, and it is not wages, and it is not freedom in the way I used to think about freedom.
It is a Tuesday evening at a table with you doing your accounts and talking about everything in the world.
It is riding beside you in the morning and knowing that we are seeing the same thing and caring about it the same way.
” He tightened his hand around hers.
“Will you marry me?” She looked at him for a long moment in the winter light.
“I have conditions,” she said.
“I expected nothing less,” he said.
“The land stays in my name,” she said.
“The Dawson place stays the Dawson place.
Any arrangement we make, legal and practical, recognizes my ownership.
” “Agreed,” he said without hesitation.
“And we decide things together,” she said.
“I am not asking for a foreman.
I am asking for a partner.
” “That is all I want to be,” he said.
She looked at the mountains.
She looked at the land spread around her, the land her family had built, the land she had kept alone through two hard winters and intended to keep indefinitely.
She looked at the man on the dun horse who had ridden to her fence on a cold October morning and helped without being asked and said true things without being prompted, and had not once suggested that her self-sufficiency was a problem to be solved.
“Yes,” she said.
He brought her hand to his mouth and pressed his lips to her knuckles through the leather of the glove, and it was such a simple thing, but the weight of it went all the way through her.
The winter deepened.
They were not yet married, because these things required some arrangement, and because Clara was not a woman to be rushed into anything.
But the quality of the space between them changed after that afternoon in the north pasture in a way that was visible to anyone paying attention.
Which in Clearwater meant everyone.
Pete Larson’s wife, Sarah, came over on a Tuesday with a jar of preserved summer beets and sat in Clara’s kitchen and did not attempt to be subtle at all.
“He is a good man,” Sarah said, pouring her own coffee without waiting to be offered.
“He is,” Clara agreed.
“Pete says he is the best hand he has had in 10 years,” Sarah said.
“And that is coming from Pete, who is tighter with a compliment than a rusted jar lid.
” “He is good with the cattle,” Clara said.
“He is good with a great many things, apparently,” Sarah said, and her eyes were very knowing.
“He built a fence section for the Hendersons last week without being asked, just because he saw it needed doing.
He helped Reverend Holt stack firewood.
He gives old Hector credit at the store when Hector is short, and he does not make a performance of it.
” She set her cup down.
“A man like that does not stay unsettled forever.
Someone would have found him eventually.
” “He found himself here,” Clara said.
“He followed himself here,” Sarah said.
“On a dun horse, crossing a north pasture, drawn by something he could not have explained at the time, but that seems very clear now.
” Clara looked at her old friend with a warmth that was mixed with the very specific exasperation that Sarah Larson had been producing in her since they were girls.
“We are engaged,” she said.
Sarah’s face broke into a smile that filled the kitchen.
“I know,” she said.
“Pete told me.
” “Eli asked his permission to speak to Pete about it, and Pete told me, and I am extremely bad at keeping this sort of news to myself, so I came over.
” “You came over under the pretense of beets,” Clara said.
“I came over for both reasons,” Sarah said.
“The beets are real.
” The question of Marcus Webb did not resolve itself quietly.
On a Thursday morning in the second week of January, Clara rode out to the north pasture to check the herd and found the fence she and Eli had mended in October knocked down again.
Not by weather, not by an animal, but deliberately.
The post had not been broken by force from the inside.
It had been pulled, the ground around it disturbed in the particular pattern that boots leave, not hooves.
She stood looking at it for a long time in the January cold, and then she rode back to the house and saddled the mare for the longer ride to the Larson place.
Eli was in Pete’s barn when she arrived and he read her expression before she said a word.
“What happened?” he said, not as a question.
She told him.
He listened without interrupting.
“We are going to town.
” he said.
“Eli, we are going to the sheriff’s office and we are going to file a formal complaint with specific documentation, including the notes from my fence survey in December.
” he said.
“And then I am going to speak to Marcus Webb directly.
” “Eli, that I am not going to threaten him.
” he said, reading her concern.
“I am going to inform him, as a neighbor and as your intended, that I am aware of what is happening and that I have documentation.
And that if it continues, I will pursue every legal avenue available, which in 1882 Wyoming is not nothing, especially with Pete Larson willing to testify to Webb’s history of boundary disputes.
” She looked at him for a moment.
“Pete is willing to testify?” “Pete has been wanting to say something official about Webb for 3 years.
” Eli said.
“He just needed a formal complaint to attach it to.
” They went to town together.
Sheriff Aldrin was visibly uncomfortable with the visit, but faced with the written fence survey, the description of the January damage, and the entirely composed presence of Eli Crane explaining the legal framework of property damage claims in a quiet and very informed way, he agreed to open an official record.
The conversation with Webb happened in the street outside the general store because Webb was there when they arrived and it would have been a kind of evasion to avoid it.
Eli spoke to him the way he did most things, directly and without raising his voice.
And what he said was essentially what he had told Clara he would say.
Webb listened with his arms crossed and his expression cycling through several varieties of displeasure.
And when Eli was done, Webb looked at Clara.
“You brought yourself a watchdog.
” he said.
“I have always been my own watchdog, Mr. Webb.
” she said.
“This is my partner.
” Webb looked at Eli for a long moment with calculation in his eyes and Eli met it with simple, level patience.
And eventually Webb turned and walked away without saying anything further.
It was not a resolution, exactly.
But the fence on the north pasture was not touched again.
They were married on the 14th of March, 1883.
It was a Saturday, which was practical because most of the town could attend a Saturday wedding without abandoning their working week.
The church was small, as it always was, and Mr.s.
Abernathy made the wedding cake, which she had apparently been planning since November when she first observed the two of them dancing at the church supper.
The cake was layered apple with dried currant filling and it was, as advertised, very good.
Clara wore her mother’s wedding dress, which had been packed in cedar and lavender since 1858 and which fit her with only minor alterations.
It was ivory silk that had gone slightly cream with age, with a high collar and buttons down the back and sleeves that came to points at her wrists.
And she wore her hair down for the occasion, which she almost never did, because she knew Eli had never seen it entirely loose and she wanted to see his face when he did.
The expression on his face when she came down the aisle of the little church was everything she had wanted it to be, unguarded, thoroughly overcome.
He recovered his composure within a breath or two, but for that first moment, he was completely without defenses and she carried the image of it for the rest of her life.
The vows were traditional and they meant them.
And when Eli slid the ring he had had made in Laramie onto her finger, a simple gold band with a single small garnet set into it, she had to work to keep her voice level for the final words because the weight of the ring and the weight of the moment were together something substantial and joyful.
Pete Larson cried, which surprised no one who knew him.
Sarah Larson did not cry, which also surprised no one, but she squeezed Clara’s hand so hard afterward that the bones ached pleasantly.
They spent their wedding night in the Dawson house, which was now also the Crane house, though the legal documentation preserved Clara’s ownership as she had stipulated.
And Eli had not only agreed to this arrangement, but had advocated for it himself to the notary, saying that the land had been in her family’s hands and would remain so.
The fire burned low and the house was warm and they were together.
And there is a particular kind of happiness that exists in the moment when a thing that you have worked toward and hoped for without letting yourself hope for it too directly finally arrives.
And that is what that night was.
Not perfect in any manufactured sense, but true.
Quiet and warm and entirely real.
In April, Eli closed the purchase of the 20 acres from Pete Larson.
They spent three Sundays together walking the new parcel, planning.
The land was good, rocky in places, but the flat lower section that had water access from the creek that crossed Clara’s north pasture.
They sat on the tailgate of the wagon and drew diagrams on the backs of old mail envelopes.
A small cattle operation.
A breeding program using the Dawson herd as the foundation.
Eventually a bunkhouse if they could hire a hand or two.
A kitchen garden on the south slope of the new land where the soil was deepest.
“This will take time.
” Eli said, looking at the raw acreage.
“Everything worth having does.
” she said.
He put his arm around her and she leaned into him and they looked at their land together, all 60 acres of it now.
And the mountains were the same as they had always been, enormous and permanent and entirely indifferent, which was somehow comforting.
The summer of 1883 was a building summer in every sense of the word.
Eli fenced the new parcel with a combination of their labor and two hired hands from town, whom Clara interviewed herself and approved herself, because she was not about to leave the hiring decisions to anyone else on her own property.
One was a young man named Thomas, 20 years old and fresh from Illinois, earnest and willing if a little soft in the hands, which 3 months of ranch work cured quickly.
The other was an older Shoshone man named Running Bear, who had been working cattle operations in the valley for years and who had a reputation for understanding livestock in a way that went beyond simple experience.
Clara had heard him recommended by three separate ranchers and she hired him directly and paid him the same rate as Thomas, which was not the universal practice and which Running Bear acknowledged with a single serious nod that told her he understood exactly what she was doing.
Running Bear had seen a great deal in his years in the Wyoming territory, more than Clara could fully imagine.
The steady erosion of his people’s land and life under the pressure of the treaties that were made and broken and remade in worse terms.
The particular injustice of watching the landscape that had sustained the Shoshone people for generations become cattle range and homesteads.
He did not speak of this unprompted and Clara did not press because she understood that it was not her story to manage.
But she made certain that he was treated with the same respect she expected for herself.
And when a passing wagon driver made a remark on the second week that Clara did not care for, she corrected it so immediately and so clearly that the subject never came up again.
Eli and Running Bear developed the kind of quiet mutual regard that forms between men who do good work together and trust each other’s judgment in the field.
By August, Running Bear was effectively the third authority on the operation and Thomas had stopped being soft-handed and started being genuinely useful.
By September, the new parcel had its fence, a water trough system running from the creek, and the beginning of a proper cattle shelter for winter.
Clara’s original herd had grown by 12 head through the spring calving season and they moved six of the younger animals to the new land for the fall grazing.
It was also in September that Clara became certain with the particular certainty that women arrive at before they are ready to speak it aloud, that the household was going to grow in a way that had nothing to do with cattle.
She told Eli on a Sunday evening when the lamp was low and the dishes were done and they were sitting together on the porch in the last warm air of a dying Wyoming summer.
She had thought about how to say it.
She had thought about saying it carefully and building to it.
And then she simply said, “We are going to have a child.
” He went very still beside her.
She turned to look at him and his profile against the evening sky was doing something she had not seen it do before, which was struggling.
His jaw tightened and then his expression broke open entirely and he turned to her and he was not, she realized, struggling with difficulty.
He was struggling with the size of the feeling.
He put his forehead against hers without saying anything and she felt him breathe, one long careful breath, and then he said, “Are you well?” “I am very well,” she said.
“Good,” he said.
“Good.
” And then he said nothing else for a while because there was nothing else needed.
They told Pete and Sarah the following Sunday, and Sarah cried this time, and Pete did not, which reversed their respective performances from the wedding and made everyone laugh.
The pregnancy was not easy in the way that the winter was not easy.
Meaning that it was manageable but demanding, and required her to accept certain adjustments to her daily workload with more grace than she naturally felt.
Eli managed this with such careful tact that she almost did not notice the adjustments being made, which was the only way they could have been made without causing a genuine argument.
He moved the heavier tasks to himself and Thomas and Running Bear without announcement, redistributed rather than restricted.
And when she noticed and said something, he said only, “I am adjusting the workload to the season.
The season is winter, and we have the extra hands.
” “The season is not winter,” she said.
“It is October.
It is heading toward winter very deliberately,” he said.
She accepted this because it was not entirely wrong and because she loved him and because she was genuinely tired in a way that was new to her, and she did not have the energy to be stubborn about all of it.
The child came in April.
It was a hard birth because first births often are, and the doctor from Clearwater rode out in the early hours, and Sarah Larson sat with Clara through the long night.
And Eli sat outside the bedroom door and did something Clara later learned was pray, which she had not known he did, and found that she was glad of.
The baby was a boy.
He arrived red-faced and loud at 4:00 in the morning on the 9th of April, 1884, and when the doctor put him in Eli’s arms for the first time, Eli stood in the bedroom doorway with the lamp behind him and the baby small and indignant in his hands, and the expression on his face was so entirely stripped of everything except wonder that Clara, who was exhausted beyond almost all language, found herself smiling.
“He is remarkable,” Eli said.
“He is very loud,” she said.
“Remarkable and loud,” he said.
“He takes after you.
You have about 48 hours of goodwill from this event,” she said, “and then I will not accept that kind of remark.
” He came and sat beside her on the bed and placed the baby carefully in her arms, and they sat together in the lamplight while April tried its best to turn warm outside, and the baby gradually stopped being offended by the world and settled into the specific gravity of a sleeping infant.
“Henry,” Clara said.
It had been her father’s name.
“Henry,” Eli agreed.
They named him Henry James Crane, the James for Eli’s father, and he proved to be exactly the kind of child that his dramatic entrance promised, which was to say that he was vocal and opinionated from the beginning and showed no signs of becoming otherwise.
The seasons moved.
Henry grew.
Thomas, their hired hand, met and married a girl from town and stayed on.
And his wife, a sensible young woman named Ruth who had been born in Kansas and had no romantic illusions about ranch life, took over the kitchen garden with such enthusiasm and expertise that the operation expanded considerably within 2 years.
| Continue reading…. | ||
| Next » | ||
