Neil deGrasse Tyson Finally Takes UFOs Seriously
Take me to your leader.
Perspectives on your first alien encounter.
Who would you expect to write a book like that?
Maybe a journalist in quotes.
Maybe somebody who had crop circles pop up allegedly in their backyard or someone who saw something but uh is from a very limited set of English-speaking countries.
Nope.
One of the most famous and in my opinion foremost scientists in America, Mr.
Neil Degrasse Tyson, professor, physicist, astrophysicist, science guy.
What does it mean that he is writing about UAPs?
Well, he just decided to turn the whole thing on its head.
And he says, “The time has come for what?”
I’m Chris Cuomo.
Welcome to the Chris Cuomo Project.
I had to sit down with the esteemed professor because how is an astrophysicist talking to UAP talk?
And why is he producing a work that takes this really, really seriously?
Here’s the answer.
Because it is.
Don’t take it from me.
Take it from the science guy, >> Neil Degrasse Tyson.
>> Dude, thanks for having me back.
>> I got to tell you, I just especially these days, you are just everything.
Uh you are something I’ve been watching, you know, to get ready for this.
I was looking at so much social media about where you’ve been.
And of course, there’s a new book out.
That’s why I hooked them.
But the idea of, and here’s what’s so interesting to me about uh the the new book is that it’s going to shock people.
And I’ll tell you why.
You are so valuable right now.
Because of how you apply physics and how you use science and >> and critical thinking >> and critical thinking, right?
I wear the shirt.
You live it.
Right?
So you don’t need the shirt.
If you had it be like duh, you know, might as well your shirt might as well say Neil on it.
Uh, but you know, so there’s such value in that and then this book comes out and I would have never, now I know you personally, but I would have never imagined if I didn’t know Neil Degrass Tyson, well, he’s not talking extraterrestrials.
He’s the debunker.
He’s, don’t bring that my way.
I’m an astrophysicist and I’m married to one and I think all my kids do that also.
So I’m like two, three generations deep of sciency.
Don’t bring that noise my way.
You say quite the opposite, my friend.
Why would you write about extraterrestrial life?
>> Yeah.
So what began to happen if you go back long enough, not that long ago, a few decades ago, uh most of the many of the accounts of UFOs and alien abductions and things were people who didn’t otherwise have title or or integrity that their station in life would grant them.
There was the farmer in his back 40.
There was junken revelers at 2 a.m.
Staggering out of the bar.
And it would be their accounts of UFOs that would get reported on.
And beginning a few years ago, and all of you in the media just ate it up when various whistleblowers and and insiders, >> News Nation has covered this more than anybody and had more of the whistleblowers than anyone else.
And they ain’t farmers.
>> There there you go.
They’re not farmers.
They’re not drunken revelers.
And there’s a parade of them.
Many of them former, you know, ex-military >> ex exhence agency officers and under oath in front of Congress.
By the way, this is the last and only time I remember the in the past decade where both houses of Congress were just together with one investigative purpose.
That was a uh I was quite impressed by that.
Aliens brought us together is what that was.
So when these people of high rank started reporting, I said, “All right, I have to jump in here.
I I can’t stay silent.
I have to I have to be a participant in what’s going on >> because of what happened to you when you got beamed up >> and and you went up there meet wrestler came down as this.
” Just cuz I wanted to be beamed up didn’t mean I got beamed up.
Okay.
>> It would explain some things because from the wrestling captain in high school to being, you know, captain science is was a little bit of a leak.
>> Okay.
You think they they put a chip in me when I was up there?
>> What’s a theory?
>> Uh, no.
I actually had a theory.
You have a hypothesis.
Okay.
>> Oh, listen to this.
>> Let’s keep that straight.
>> I’ll take an axiom.
>> So, you decided to jump.
>> You want a lema?
You want me a lema?
>> So, That was a good routine.
We should take that on the road.
>> Yeah, it’s about all I got though.
I really can’t stay up with you for very long.
Um, so I just thought we need we have to anchor some of this conversation and and little did I realize I had been I mean I knew this but I didn’t feel it until I decided to put the book put words to page.
For decades, I’ve been contemplating Hollywood’s attempts to portray aliens, what they look like, how creative were they, how creative were they not, what was the intelligence they were given, how what powers they had.
And all of this is floating in my head.
And I said, now that we have high-ranking whistleblowers, let me jump in and participate in this conversation.
And I thought to myself, let’s take aliens as a given.
And then talk about what that would be like if they landed.
What should you say to them?
If they asked to take you to your leader, who would you choose?
Let’s have these conversations rather than continue to push it off to the side or kick the can down the street.
I said, let’s do it.
So I the first opening chapter is alien to us and I highlight all the things that creative storytellers have imagined would be different about aliens relative to us.
Okay, that’s easy to do.
It’s just a it’s it’s a compendium.
The second chapter, alien to them are things in our lives that we take for granted that we don’t think of as alien, but we’d be completely alien to an alien.
For for example, uh suppose an alien comes down, you become friends, okay?
And then they’re down for like half a day and you say, “Excuse me, friendly alien.
I have to lay down horizontally and become semicomaosse for onethird of Earth’s rotation.”
>> You think they wouldn’t be into sleep?
>> I’m just saying that’s a weird thing.
Okay, maybe they the aliens go to sleep, but that’s a big assumption if they come from another planet.
Okay, so uh that’s a weird request of them you’d have to make.
And be aware that that looks alien to them.
Here’s another one.
Suppose they land in LA, okay, in the 405, 12 lanes across.
They don’t see any humans, no pedestrian cuz nobody walks anywhere in LA.
They’re just cars.
The alien might think that is the life form on Earth.
This thing, this metal machine, that’s the life form.
And then they’ll see one of the car haulers go by.
That’s a pregnant one.
That that is multiple the whole litter ready to come out of that one.
And then they look at like fast food stores.
This gets me just as a New Yorker.
LA people will wait in line in their car.
A slow line to order fast food, hand it to them through their window and then they eat it in the car.
Okay.
So, as far as the alien is concerned, the car is the thing and if one of them gets injured, another thing comes back to bring it away to fix it.
All everything is automobile driven.
So, you have to we we need to be sensitive to what we might look like to aliens.
So there’s a whole section in there getting rid of your ego or tamping down your ego.
Another one, alien comes up to you in there some appendage there.
You you don’t grab it and shake it like you’re greeting it.
You don’t know what part of the alien that is that you just grabbed.
And I don’t think you want to know, at least not up front.
>> Okay.
>> So little things like that.
So, in a way, it’s a primer for what to look out for, what to be cautious of, what to, you know, what what to leave at home.
And in your first meeting with an alien, you’re not only representing yourself, you’re representing your country, you’re representing humans, you’re representing Earth.
So, I recommend at that time, you leave your flatearther friends behind.
You You want to leave a good impression on the alien, and the flatearther will not leave a good impression on the alien.
Not knowing the shape of your planet is not a good start.
>> It’s not a good start.
You want to at least have some hope in our intelligence.
And uh also it would be a wrong time to bring your religious friend in who would declare that the creator of the universe is someone in whose image we are shaped.
>> Therefore, not the alien.
It’d be a hard cell because the alien got here in a spaceship and you know we only just recently left low earth orbit for the first time in 56 years 54 years.
So um so be judicious about who you bring to meet the alien versus who you don’t.
Joe Rogan doesn’t believe that we uh landed on the moon.
So even though he’s like got a big cultural presence right now, you keep him off the short list of who comes in.
>> Yeah.
Yeah.
So if he doesn’t think we landed on the moon, we live in a free country.
I I don’t have any problems with people not believing we landed on the moon.
I just don’t just make sure they don’t become head of NASA.
Okay?
Leave them out of s positions of high space responsibility.
Uh do you remember Kyrie Irving was a basketball player?
I only remembered this when he was with the net with the Celtics.
He was a big flat-earther.
He had all kinds of social media post and I said to what do you think that he thinks this?
And I said, “He’s a basketball player.
You know, where he works professionally has to be flat.
>> It’s his lived experience.
>> It’s his lived experience.”
So, I got no problem with that.
So, so I I just don’t want aliens to think we’re just raving idiots.
>> So, how do you square?
So, so here’s the problem with somebody like you and what you mean by the way, which by the way, Neil does not like this topic of discussion, but it matters to me because >> you know what I’m like.
I’m talking about anything.
Go on.
>> Every time I’ve brought this up, you’re like, “What?
>> Bring it on.
>> You matter.
>> Bring it.
>> You matter.
You are a proxy for our pride of intelligence and intellect.
It’s like >> I don’t I I don’t like carrying that responsibility.
>> I totally get it.
I’m just lucky.
It’s not a thing for me.
It’s not >> never been accused of this.
Uh, which is, you know, a fairly short list of things I haven’t been accused of.
So, here’s the thing, though.
How do you square the integrity of your intellectual pursuits with this topic when a lot of people, major players dismiss it out of hand?
>> Okay.
So, I’ve it’s an important question and my reply is um you know the the the the battlecry I need a witness.
>> Mhm.
>> That it’s a courtroom drama.
>> I need a witness said no scientist ever.
In science, eyewitness testimony does not count as evidence.
Evidence is evidence.
Testimony that is filtered through your brain, ear, you know, we we’ve known since kindergarten.
When you play telephone, information starts out over here.
Six children later is completely different.
Every person is influencing the objective truth of what began this conversation of telephone.
So, we’ve known from early on and it doesn’t get better in adulthood.
In fact, it gets a little worse because we become we take on belief systems and commitments of our philosophy, be it religious, cultural, political philosophies that completely shape or the lenses through which different people look see the same event differently.
Okay?
Just look at how different uh coming from your world, look at how different news agencies report the same story.
>> Okay?
You’d wonder is this the same planet?
>> All right.
So, so the scientist requires evidence.
And when we say hard evidence, we mean not your testimony.
All right.
I decided in a book such as this, let everyone be telling the truth.
I’m back up.
Probably 3/4 or more of all UFO sightings have natural explanation.
Even UFO enthusiasts know this and will confess to this.
All right.
There’s always some little bit that has no explanation.
If you’re alien adjacent the moment you can’t explain aliens.
So this resembles from antiquity what’s called god of the gaps >> for what philosophers call god of the gaps.
There’s a storm raging on the coastline of Greece.
Poseidon is angry.
You don’t know what caused the storm but you know Poseidon.
God of the gaps.
Okay.
So any any place where science has yet to tread, you’re comfortable thinking that there’s God or gods that have something to do with it.
In modern times, that’s taken on the patina of alien of the gaps, except that doesn’t have the same ring as God of the gaps.
So I I for the book I invented the phrase aliens of our ignorance and then you have the asinance of the vowels, >> aliens of our ignorance.
So there’ll be some small percent, call it 5% of sightings that have no obvious easy explanation.
The alien enthusiast says aliens and I’m saying we just don’t know what it is.
>> Yeah.
You I asked you about this once before and you said why would anyone who studies have the arrogance to believe that there’s no possibility that there’s any other form of life anywhere when every time we measure the universe it is bigger than the last time we checked >> now that’s a different question that’s is there life in the universe versus is there life visiting restricted military airspace of the US government these are two different questions okay So with this small percent that an alien enthusiast says is alien, I’m saying,
Okay, but the time has come where we already know you’re stockpiling aliens in Area 51 and in the back shed and alien body parts and alien saucer parts and alien reversed engineering and it’s all in the back shed.
Fine.
Um, until you fork up an actual alien, this entire operation is all about belief.
>> Mhm.
>> The question anyone asks you is not, are aliens real?
Is it, do you believe in aliens?
Do you believe in them?
Do you believe in elephants?
>> Well, I do cuz I’ve touched them.
>> Thank you.
Well, there it is.
Okay.
If only a few dozen people had ever seen an elephant in the world and you paraded them in front of Congress under sworn testimony.
I swear these things exist that there’s an animal is huge and it’s it’s the size of a truck and it’s got a nose.
No.
And it’s got a big rubbery thing hanging off its front and it could drink water out of it and it could and it eats and it could grab things.
Has two big teeth that stick upwards and they’re big and shiny and smooth and it’s got ears the size of of bed sheets and the legs are the size of of tree stumps.
And we’re just listening to these testim like that’s kind of weird, dude.
Can you draw one?
And they all try to draw it but they’re not good illustrators and it just looks like some hybrid animal that no one has ever seen before.
That’s a two-hour documentary right there investigating these illustrations.
You know how to turn that into a 10-minute documentary?
Bring out an elephant.
Okay.
Elephant comes out in the first five minutes and rolling credits are the second five minutes.
And no one after that would ever have to say, “Do you believe in elephants?”
So I am saying because we have high-ranking people and because they’re saying it’s in the government, then it’s no longer a cover up.
By the way, let’s distinguish cover up from secret.
Of course, the military has secret things.
It’s not a cover up if it’s an official secret.
>> A cover up would be something that you >> hiding something screwed up >> that that you that you would otherwise know, but they’re h No, the of course the government has top secret things.
No one is arguing that.
And in the the Pentagon files, these are classified documents.
>> Support for the Chris Cuomo project comes from Shopify.
Listen, small business is the heart of America.
Small business is hard.
Okay?
And often what determines your success is the business behind your business.
Meaning, who’s helping you sell, who’s helping optimize where people see your advertising, where people see your products, how they get to your site, what their experience is there, how the click-through rate goes, how things are presented.
It’s tricky and a lot of times that’s not your expertise.
Hello Shopify.
Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world.
10% of all e-commerce in the US.
Shopify.
Okay.
So designing all right uh hundreds of readytouse templates so that you know Shopify can help you build an online store that matches your brand’s style.
So, it takes the thinking out of it and it puts you back in your depth of making choices versus having to make up choices.
Do you understand?
Best yet, Shopify is your commerce expert with worldclass expertise in everything, including inventory, shipping, returns, all of these things that you never think about.
Okay?
And what if you get stuck?
They have an award-winning 247 customer support.
All right?
So any way you look at it, if you want to be better at business, you got to be in business with better.
And that is Shopify.
And they can have that line if they want it.
It’s time to turn those whatifs into a kaching Shopify.
Shopify today.
Sign up for your $1 a month trial at shopify.com/chrisc.
Go to shopify.com/chrisc.
Use my name to get the special deal.
Shopify.com/chrisc.
So for me, it’s a transparency story, not uh from the physical metaphysical uh perspective that we’re discussing within the book, which I think is is a very clever way to approach this from a different angle.
Um, and I’m not surprised by that given who wrote it.
But for me, it’s >> because there’s a whole section of the book that analyzes alien powers and can they make themselves invisible or transparent.
But going back section, >> I’ll tell you what, watching Lucy the other night again, uh the movie with Scarlett Johansson and Martin Freeman where they use this clever really speaking of clever.
So dolphins, you know this, dolphins use as mammals use more of their brain than we do.
They’re the mammal that uses their brain the most.
It’s like 27%.
>> Their brain is bigger than our brain.
But plus that whole movie premise was based on a false understanding, a false read of what >> the the original >> I’ve been working on my echolocation.
>> How how’s it working for you?
>> So So just to be clear, uh if memory serves, the original quote was because you can’t you can’t do experiments on people’s brains.
It’s not ethical.
But what you can do if someone has a brain injury, you can test what remains that still works and you can say ah that part of the brain must control language or vision or whatever.
Okay.
>> I think the quote was the brain is so complex we only know what 10% of it is used for.
>> Right?
>> That became we only use 10% of our brain.
True.
And that’s not going away because teachers use that all the time.
You you can use much more of your brain and it’s just embedded in what we want to be true.
>> It is a false premise.
>> It’s a false premise and has become it’s become legend or mythology.
Okay.
So to the point where is foundational to the movie Lucy.
>> Yes.
>> And and I comment in Lucy in Lucy she’s altering the molecular structure of matter.
>> Yes.
>> And I take issue with that in the book.
It’s not only her.
It’s in the movie Phenomenon >> with um John Travolta.
Yeah.
>> He gets hit by lightning or something and he becomes really smart.
>> Yeah.
>> I don’t mind you becoming smart, >> but since when does becoming smart mean you can move objects with your brain, right?
>> That this No, if you’re smart, you can solve problems faster and better.
Okay.
Put them to solve the cancer problem or the you know nuclear fusion or whatever.
But to start moving matter, no, that no, that’s not you don’t get that just by having more neurosaptic firings.
That’s not a next thing for being smarter.
And you might say if there was any inkling of that existing at all, then Albert Einstein would would at least be able to like move a penny a little bit, right?
Just just a little bit.
You know, if Scarlett Johansson and and Morgan F, >> he was the professor guy.
Scarlett Johansson and John Travolta in phenomenon.
If they could like spin cups and do things, at least Einstein could have just shifted it over.
But no, no.
And do you know LIGO, the laser interpherometer gravitational wave observatory, which detects the collision of black holes billions of miles away?
This is a ripple through the fabric of spaceime that watches over this specially designed telescope that could detect the ripple.
And you know the
Level at which it detects the ripple 100th hundth the diameter of a proton.
That’s what gets measured once they removed all the other things that could influence those atoms.
My point is if you have brain power that could influence objects, we would detect that in that device.
We would know you were messing with with matter because we can detect it.
You can’t just move something without influencing the structure of the matter that’s over where you’re where you’re influencing it.
So, so I want to anchor people’s imaginations with this book.
Say, “Here are the laws of physics that we measured on Earth, and they apply across time and across the universe.
Those are going to hold the aliens accountable.
They’ll have great technologies for sure.”
Took us 66 years only to go from the Wright brothers to walking on the moon.
>> That’s technology.
>> Mhm.
>> Uh there wasn’t some new law of physics that enabled that.
That’s technology.
So, I’m giving the aliens technology.
But I’m saying, >> well, if they figure out how to get here from that far away, >> then clearly they got some technology, uh, if not wormholes or something really cool.
But I want this conversation to transition from I believe in aliens to of course because we’ve seen the alien.
>> Either there’s a high resolution photo of one or and nowadays it’s even harder because AI can just make a high resolution.
>> That is that’s what pisses me off.
It made it harder >> is that we have they have the answers.
And I’m not saying the the the the big shiny answers.
I’m saying they have been spending hundreds of millions of dollars for a long time.
>> Wait, who’s they?
>> The government.
>> No, wait, wait, pause.
The military.
I want them to investigate stuff in the sky that could harm me.
Yeah, I’m going to use this part of the budget.
Investigate everything and classify whatever you think you have to.
Go ahead.
Now, what’s your problem with $100 million?
>> Not a hundred.
I don’t I don’t care how many billions, whatever it is.
>> They have the ability to say >> yes, we have found things.
Um, >> and the whistleblowers have already said that >> and they are they are from here or we don’t think they are from here.
>> They’ve already said that.
>> So, they have, but they won’t confirm it.
So, these poor guys, >> no, the whistleblowers are confirming it.
>> I know, but they are getting hung out to dry.
Grush, Lu Alzando, these other guys, they’ve all been they’ve all been here.
Okay, I talk to these guys on a regular basis because I believe in their commitment to the transparency and they have left these guys out and tarnish their record.
>> What I’m saying is that the Pentagon releases are all consistent with everything they’re saying.
So for me, the Pentagon files are affirm what we’ve already been told.
And so for as far as I’m concerned, it absolves them of is that the right word?
Absol it it verifies at least in spirit where they were coming from.
Fine.
So I’m saying bring out the alien.
I will sit back on my chair, watch TV, catch up on some shows waiting for you to bring out the alien.
And then no one will ever have to ask again, do you believe in aliens?
>> And the idea that here’s what doesn’t work for me.
Again, just from a transparency model.
Yeah.
No, you can’t handle it.
No, I don’t buy that.
I don’t.
First of all, I don’t buy buy that.
>> You’re already telling me you got aliens.
>> That’s right.
>> It’s in fact, bring out the alien to be anticlimactic at that point.
You already told me.
Plus, Hollywood has prepped us.
What?
We don’t We haven’t thought about aliens before.
Excuse me.
Okay.
We got another movie coming out in a few days.
Uh, Disclosure Day from Steven Spielberg.
That’ll be his fourth alien movie.
I think >> it’s the sequel to um Close Encounters of the uh Is it a sequel?
Yeah, that’s what they say is that it’s the following.
>> I didn’t know that.
Okay.
Close.
So, he’s got four alien movies.
I think ET, Close Encounters, there’s a third one in there, and then this one.
Uh so, so we’re already prepped.
So, I the the notion that I’m not showing it to you because you can’t handle it.
Well, clearly you can handle it because you know about it and your whistleblowers told us about it and Hollywood has already been there.
So bring out the alien.
So physics led to metaphysics and the greatest minds have transited these spaces from what is observable uh to what is arguable and one is a branch of philosophy and another is a branch of of straight science.
>> The difference between the metaphysics and the physicist is that the metaphysicist has no laboratory.
Right?
>> So they’re sitting in their chair contemplating how things might be or should be.
But at the end of the day, what we have come to learn is the objective truths of the universe do not follow naturally from our common sense.
And I’ve said many times, the universe is under no obligation to make sense to you.
A philosopher would have never come up with quantum physics.
It doesn’t make any sense.
Particles popping in and out of existence, quantum tunneling.
You can’t sit in the armchair and deduce that.
So we parted ways with traditional philosophers about 130 years ago um when modern physics what we call modern physics in the classroom which is relativity and quantum physics.
These things just are mindstretching right and but they’re anchored to actual observations and that is what establishes what’s objectively true not what makes sense to you.
I read something recently and you’ll you’ll help me understand slashdebunk this which is we’ve come back full circle to um you know some of the early existential philosophers like Renee Decart of if everything back here doesn’t exist because I can’t I can’t I can’t perceive it.
If I can’t perceive it, I can’t conceive of it.
And it’s all this whatever’s behind me right now is not there.
Now it’s here.
No, it’s not there.
It’s gone.
And that quantum physics is bringing it back around in terms of the nature of existence and what is and what isn’t >> except it has nothing to do with your consciousness or you as a human observer just to be clear the the system changes its state the way it’s described which is leads to so much confusion is the experiment is different if you look at it >> right >> and people thinking oh that means you
Are influencing it by because you’re thinking about no no here’s There’s an electron right there, right on the table.
Then I ask you, well, how do you know?
Well, I can see it.
No, you can’t.
You have to turn on the lights.
Turn on the lights.
A photon hits the electron.
It kicks it somewhere else.
Now, you cannot see the photon where it was.
I mean, you can’t see the the electron where it was.
So the act of observing requires you have to I I can shine light on you and you’re still sitting there.
But the tinier you get, the greater is the influence of that light on what you’re doing to the point where if you’re a particle and I turn on the light, you pop somewhere else.
So I can’t know that the particle is there because the act of knowing changes the state of the system.
That’s the qu that’s the quantum con conundrum and I shouldn’t call it a conundrum.
It’s a quantum reality.
So that’s why there’s a tradeoff between knowing where something is and measuring where something is.
It’s a trade-off.
And you can measure where it is precisely, but that’s not where it used to be.
And and and quantum physics uses a lot of a lot of probabilistic things.
The electron is somewhere here within a probability, a certain probability.
And Einstein said God does not play dice with the universe.
Yes, he does.
The difference is God doesn’t play poker.
God is not malicious with the statistics.
It doesn’t bluff.
Uh it’s pure statistics.
So um yeah, quantum physics is a whole other realm and a fascinating frontier.
We’ve got top people working on it and in it.
I would presume that aliens would be all in it too.
It’s the foundation of our IT revolution.
There’s no creation, storage, and retrieval of information without exploiting the quantum.
So, we can exploit something even if we don’t fully understand how and why it works because we can measure, >> right, >> how it works.
I say, sorry, let me be precise.
We we can exploit quantum physics even though we don’t know why it works but we know how it works.
>> Right.
>> Right.
>> How do you reconcile?
You said, you know, when you’re getting ready to meet the aliens, be be careful about who you introduce them to first because of those first >> and what part of their appendages you grab and shake.
>> That’s right.
That’s 100% right.
Plus, plus handshakes are not even earthwide.
>> In China, they don’t shake each other’s hands, right?
So, >> and I get it, by the way.
>> So, you can’t possibly think of that as universal.
>> You know who used to be ahead of the curve on this >> uh because it’s very gery with everything we do with our hands, uh is the president.
The president did not shake hands until he got into running for president.
>> You’re talking about um uh Trump.
>> Yeah.
He did not shake hands cuz he’d be like, “No, everybody’s hands are filthy.
They don’t wash your hands.
You ever been in a bathroom?”
He wasn’t wrong.
So he used to like, you know, he was an early one of these.
He was an early just a you know or fish work too.
So here’s an interesting experiment they now can do in elementary school.
Do you know the glitter?
>> Oh yeah.
>> Yeah.
Glitter is fun.
So you you you sink your hands in glitter.
The kids will do this.
You sink your hands in glitter.
Someone does it in gold glitter.
Someone does it in silver glitter.
And they just shake the hand of another kid and 10 kids down there’s the some of that glitter from their So think of the glitter as germs.
>> Oh yeah.
And there they are propagating their way through.
And you can shake hands with the other color >> glitter and you can just watch it move throughout.
>> Yeah.
As every parent knows from the cycle of illness that we go through.
So >> So, so I want what I want to be clear about is I used to spend energy when people came up to me and said, “How do you explain this observation?
What do you think this is?”
And a lot of them can be explained.
Here’s a good one.
Uh, we’re old enough to remember, a little older than you, but we’re we’re both old enough to remember.
There were these roadside flying saucers.
>> Mhm.
>> Now, think about it.
Back then, you were photographed once a year for your school picture, >> right?
>> Only two people carried cameras, journalists and tourists.
If you were neither, you had you didn’t have a camera.
So to photograph UFOs was a rare ability to to to do.
Okay.
So photos were precious.
There’d be a flying saucer there.
And I said, “Wow, that’s interesting.”
Okay.
And then when the automotive industry started making wheels without hubcaps, those photos went away.
Now, young timers instead of old-timers won’t know that a hubcap was something that was hammered onto the wheel of your car.
And if you went into a a significant pothole, >> the the jolt would knock the the the p the the hubcap off your car.
And if you’re going fast and you got the music on, you don’t even know that that happened.
So, cars dropped hub caps all the time.
>> You go along the You didn’t have to go more than a mile without finding a hub cap.
Take it and toss it.
Take a picture of it.
Bada bing.
UFO.
Okay.
No.
Flying saucer because you can see that it’s a saucer shape.
It’s not UFO if you can know what it is.
It’s an IFO.
So the fact that those went away >> is suspicious that those are faked.
Okay.
I’m allowed to say this, to ask this, and to require of people who are even who are enthusiasts that they carry this level of skepticism.
It’s honest skepticism.
And another one was uh there were all these stories of people under hypnosis recalling having been abducted.
The famous psychiatrist up in Boston, John Mack, uh made a career of interviewing people, having them tell them about they being abducted and he said if this many people are actually abducted because he had certain number of patients and a certain fraction of them under hypnosis reported abductions.
He said, “If this ratio is true in the public, then millions of people have been abducted.”
Well, that’s a bold move right there.
Okay, fine.
You’ve been abducted and anally probed.
Fine.
Today, you have a smartphone.
And you know, if you’re going to get abducted, you should be live streaming it.
There are no live streams of anybody getting abducted or getting anally probed.
That would be hard to film that one actually, now that I think about it.
But, um, so those have gone away.
So, were these abductions under hypnosis real?
Were they dredged out of the fantasies of a person’s brain at the hands of an expert psychologist?
So, you’re allowed to sort of see those trend lines as the ability to obtain data get get better and better.
So now I’m saying, “All right, whatever’s left, let’s just say you’re telling the truth, but I can’t do anything more with it until you bring up bring me the alien.”
And that’s the posture of the book.
>> I have so many people question this with a crucifix around their neck.
>> Interesting.
Well, I have a colleague who thinks that because it’s do you believe in aliens is the mantra that it’s becoming his own religion.
>> Mhm.
It’s like, “Do you believe in Jesus?
Do you believe in Muhammad?
Do you believe in Krishna?”
You only say that if they’re not sitting there in front of you with like objective evidence that isn’t the product of eyewitness testimony.
>> Uh here’s something.
This >> got a lot more proof of this than we do of the big man, by the way.
>> So, so here’s a just a slight aside.
I was in Vegas and there was a driver who picked me up, a car service, and he recognized me and he started asking questions.
A tie on.
>> No, you recognize without the without the really without the geeky tie.
>> Oh, okay.
>> So, what do you say?
>> Okay.
So, he said, “Do you uh do you value eyewitness testimony?”
And I said, you know, it can hint at something interesting, but no, it’s generally not accepted as evidence in science.
What I’ve already told you.
And he said, “Well, what about the resurrection of Jesus?”
He said, “That had two eyewitnesses cuz there were two guards at the tomb.
” And then he said, “By the way, he’s only moonlighting as a driver.
He’s a preacher during the day.”
>> Ah, >> okay.
Now, long ago, I decided if I’m ever going to engage a religious person, I should at least read the Bible and read the Quran and read Joseph Smith’s account.
I should So, otherwise, I’m just dangling nowhere in that conversation.
So, I said to him, “Both of those guards were asleep when this happened.
Did you not know this?
They do not count as eyewitnesses.”
And he he was like shocked.
He was like, because plus I just I just out Bibled him.
Okay, I I’m the skeptical scientist.
He’s trying to find eyewitness evidence of the resurrection of Jesus.
And I knew something that he didn’t or wasn’t or he had he had perhaps ignored that fact because it was important to him that this was witnessed.
>> Oh yeah.
It’s very So I’m over covering uh the ongoing conflict in the Middle East and we decide to do for Easter a resurrection special just on what do we know, what do we not know.
>> I mean, why not?
It’s a >> holy cow does this get deep f.
So these people are taking me through.
>> Wait, which people?
What do you mean?
>> So different keepers of different sacred places are explaining to me the relevance of their places.
We went all over Israel, all over the Holy Ghost.
>> Oh, you were on location.
>> Oh, yeah.
>> Oh, and these these people have like reoquaries of the pieces of the cross.
>> Oh, yeah.
Pieces of >> So, it’s deep.
Oh, man.
>> This one guy, I put my hand in there and he was like, “This is where the step of the cross was put in this hole and you know, you reach your hand down and >> that that brings in parishioners.
” >> Oh, yeah.
And they are explaining this to me.
So, there there’s two different sites that they believe are the where the tomb was.
Okay.
And the people in each of those places, the the tears, the passion that would come out of them when they were explaining how they know that this is the place and this is how and we know this and we know that and this guy’s got 90 different pedigrees and they’re they’re like real, you know, like professors and they 90 and I’m listening to it and I’m trying to, you know, we got to put this together as a
Story and I’m doing it with a producer who actually just wrote his own book about unexplained phenomena.
And we’re like, look, we got to do this right because you can’t just go through sarcastically parading these people out there because there are billions of people who believe what they’re telling you right now.
>> Two billion.
>> So, you know, two billion.
>> You got to you got to respect it for what it is and how and get their versions and and what their bases are of them and the points of skepticism.
So, we did what you did.
We reverse the mechanism.
Instead of saying prove to me that this happened, we started with they believe it happened and here are the points of skepticism that they’ve had to defeat over time about why they existed.
>> But it and that’s a healthy posture.
I mean that’s any good scientific investigation.
So and that’s and you captured the soul of this book.
>> Yes.
>> Okay.
But go on, finish.
Well, what I realized at some point in the editing process when we were getting ready to put it on TV, well, this is going to be a nightmare because no matter what side of it you’re on, you’re going to be upset when you watch this special because if you’re a believer, you’re going to say, man, you’re skeptical for a guy who’s supposedly
Catholic, you know, and Italian Catholic at that.
>> And then I have to explain the idea of being raised in a tradition versus your own choices.
But then on the other side, if you are atheistic or you are an agnostic at best, how could you have spent an hour going through this [ __ ] on?
So either way, you were going to have problems.
And I remember there’s a woman who was a she was great.
She was a great Virgil for me all through um uh Jerusalem.
And she takes me on the the the walkway of Jesus, which isn’t the original walkway because it was on the other side of town and they moved it.
And there is a stone that so many pilgrims/tourists have put their hand on that it has been worn six, seven in deep.
That’s how many hands have been rubbing on their >> taking rock material on their skin.
That’s exactly right.
Right.
Right.
So, I’m putting my hand in the hole and as I’m putting my hand in there and I was like, “Wow, this is a deep hole, man.
A lot of people put their hand in here.”
She’s like, “Yeah, now that’s not the original stone.
The original stone would have.”
And I’m like looking at her.
I was like, “This isn’t even the right stone where Jesus put his hand against the wall.”
>> So, the power of wanting things to be true.
>> How do you handle that when the idea of well, if I can’t prove it, then I can’t believe it.
Um with with faith.
H how do you deal with that?
Because it plays into the idea of what your book is about and you’re right that it is becoming a point of religion.
>> Let that’s a very important point.
Let me get back to it after I give one example about how to come at it with questions in in when you turn the table.
>> So going on its third decade, the History Channels Ancient Aliens or Ancient Astronauts, whatever they call ancient aliens, >> uh very popular series.
They go back and they find etchings on walls and caves and there’s like a bubble head character with rays of light beams coming levitated all commander of things and they say this must be aliens that visited them.
Okay.
So, sure, if you don’t think the these other things, you you would think they’re aliens if you didn’t otherwise imagine.
Maybe these are drawings by caveman kindergarten classes.
Okay.
Okay.
Have you considered that?
Or maybe they had gods and ascribed powers to their gods.
>> Mhm.
>> Just the way we do in our fresco.
There’s Jesus levitating there with beams of light coming out of his head.
Are you saying that was an alien?
No, you’re saying that was Jesus.
All right.
>> Although some do say >> some do.
There’s a whole there’s an alien uh religion, an official alien religion where the our the creators of us are aliens and I think they’re in the Pleaides or something.
I talk about it in the book.
But so that’s that’s a subset of the whole thing.
Uh my only point is that you are denying these ancient peoples their own imagination for how they portray their gods.
>> Mhm.
>> When we do this all the time.
>> All the time.
>> We have centaurs and minotaurs and and we >> all kinds of iconography.
>> All kinds of iconography.
And especially of course back in the pagan era with with multiple gods.
Uh and then there’s the snakes for hair gorgon.
Um >> Medusa.
>> Medusa.
Come on now.
>> Yeah.
>> All right.
And you if Medusa showed up back then, you’d say, “Oh, this is an alien.”
No, they’re just imagining it.
Give them some imagin.
They’re still human the way we are.
So my issue there was the show is not honest enough about what could be the imagination of ancient peoples because look at our modern day imagination.
Do you know five out of the top 10 grossing films of all time involve mythical magical creatures that are not human?
And eight out of the top 10 if you include superheroes.
So our our fanciful imagination is is pays many bills in in Hollywood.
Now getting back to your point about the religion reconciling.
>> Yeah.
So in a free country as we think we still live in you have the right to believe whatever you want provided does not subtract from the rights of your fellow citizens.
Whatever you want.
So, I’m not here to have you lose your religion.
But if by believing that you’re going to make a statement about the physical world that I can test, I’m going to test it.
And if it differs from what you are saying, I’m not going to follow your line of reasoning just because it fulfills your divine text.
And Galileo knew this.
He’s a religious guy.
But he said, “The Bible, the Bible tells you how to go to heaven, not how the heavens go.”
That’s good.
>> That is good.
>> That’s good.
And Leonardo 1542 was it somewhere around there said the greatest deception men suffer is from their own opinions.
So we’ve known this for 500 years.
How many scientists do you know who seriously have faith?
>> Yeah, I would say uh might be one in 10.
Uh and I’m not including the Jews in that number because there many Jewish atheists in the sense that they actively practice all the high holidays, right?
As do many Christians.
Of course, we have Christmas and you’re not literally thinking anything Christian perhaps, but there are many Jews, especially among my colleagues, that they’ll leave an empty seat for Elijah at the sader table and not literally thinking.
Plus, you have to unlock the front door, too.
>> Oh, yeah.
>> I don’t know what hood you live in.
But >> Jews are nothing if not polite.
They’re not going to just break through the door.
>> So, so they’ll do that without thinking that it has any literal meaning.
But what we do know is that in modern society, rituals form some of the strongest binding forces we have as a people.
So the value of that transcends whether you have a literal belief in it what it in it being true.
So I don’t concern myself.
I don’t distract myself by people who believe things that don’t otherwise adversely affect their health, their wealth, or their security, or their well-being.
If Jesus is your savior, no one is going to take that from you.
But if Jesus is your savior and somewhere in there your read of the scripture says that modern medicine is bad for you and that Jesus will cure you, you’re going to die young.
Okay?
That’s just the fact.
And the people who don’t die young and write books um they left behind everyone else who died and didn’t write books.
Dead people are not interviewed by the press.
Okay?
People forget that fact.
So So it’s not a matter of reconciling.
You can reconcile it if the Bible to you is not a science textbook.
If it’s if it’s simply a a a source of wisdom and and insight and spiritual fulfillment.
But for the longest while, biblical Genesis was the literal account of the creation.
>> Yeah.
You know, that’s one of the reasons that my father’s one of my father’s heroes, my father’s line, by the way, was, “No, Christopher, go ahead.
Say what you have.
You have an absolute right to be wrong.”
Uh, that’s what he used to say.
But >> I love that >> one of his personal heroes uh was Teard Desardan, who was a scientist, but also a priest.
And he wrote The Divine Milo, which is like a real uh bedrock of Catholicism.
And the reckoning of science and faith.
And what got him in trouble with the church was when he started to play at the no nature of proof and they were like, “Hold on a second with the proving.
We told you what it is.
That’s how it works.”
>> Yeah.
And you you should tell it what we tell you is true.
>> And he said, “The Bible, >> the Bible’s a set of stories.
Great virtues in there.
Not I’m not here to argue that it is divine speak.
I’m not saying that.
I’m saying that these these work in here and if you look at science and the mystery of everything that we don’t know plays into the idea of faith and the real and they were like no what what did you say about the Bible and well I’m just saying the Bible is not we can’t say as a scientist I can’t tell you that this is the divine word you got
To go go somewhere else for about seven eight years let’s see how you feel when you come back.
That’s what got him in trouble with the truth was him questioning something that he had to question.
>> Well, if you if you’re going to go all the way, go all the way.
You can’t go halfway if you’re going to start questioning.
>> But yeah, if you’re going to be in the proof business, you’re probably not going to find yourself in the faith business.
>> Correct.
Because if you have faith and you need proof, then you don’t really have faith because the moment you have proof for it all, then we can just call it a science and it’s no longer a faith.
>> Right.
>> There’s another line I I >> belief without faith is superstition.
Aquinus uh or Augustine said um Aquinus or Augustus I forget but it was >> belief without faith I would bet prove is is mere superstition.
>> Well to a scientist it’s all >> that’s right.
>> Well so uh I’m uncomfortable believing in things that I have to believe in to be true.
>> Right.
If that sentence made sense >> like you don’t know if you >> I don’t mind not knowing but I’m saying I I was subjected to a sequence of experiments that I devise or others to see if that idea is true.
If a faithful person requires that then they’re not really faithful.
They’re just testing it.
That’s right.
And because faith is to believe not only in the face of evidence, but in the face not in the face of evidence, in the absence of evidence, and in the presence of conflicting evidence.
>> Mhm.
>> That’s the true test of your faith there.
>> Our real hard spot, and we have many, but our real sticky bit right now is conflicting evidence.
We do not know as a culture, not the scientists, but we don’t know as a culture.
And we, this got us in trouble in the pandemic.
Gets us in trouble with our politics.
We can’t handle conflicting >> well because so yes, but what’s behind that is the public is not equipped to think statistically about their decisions and I did this research for a separate book that I wrote.
Uh >> does it bother you by the way that this may be your most successful book ever with all of the things that you’ve taught us and introduced us to?
If your how to deal with aliens when they come winds up being your number one seller, how will you feel?
>> I that’s just a Trojan horse.
I slip science every other few pages.
There’s some authentic science in there.
So, >> I hope this one sells the most just to interview about it.
How do you feel now?
How do you feel about this, Neil?
This is your big contribution to us.
>> There’s an old saying, I think I heard it from Harry Bellfonte.
He said, uh, if this if there’s a song that you hate, don’t record it because if it’s your biggest selling song, everyone will want you to sing it for the rest of your life.
He said that before.
He sang >> D.
Yep, that’s exactly it.
Uh, one of the funniest jokes I heard, um, do you remember when Night Line began?
It had Ted CPP.
>> Ted Cppel.
>> Do you know what birth night line?
Do you remember?
>> Yeah.
The Iran >> the hostages day one day five day and then it was like day 300 whatever.
Okay.
Johnny Carson I remember he was Carneck and he would give the answer but then give the question.
>> Okay.
So the answer was day.
>> Okay.
What where’s this going?
So he opens the letter.
He says, “What was the day before the hostages were taken?”
So, that was good.
I’ve never forgotten that one.
Um, so, uh, yeah, if it’s my biggest selling book, it’ll be a little awkward, but I I think I can handle it.
I No, it’s I’m just The difference is I’m no longer going to try to explain what you saw.
I’m just taking it as face value.
>> Yeah.
I also think there’s a practical application to it.
So when we again I was over in Israel and uh specifically just uh north and east of there across into Lebanon uh that’s the border there and drones uh they’re telling a joke in Ukraine and in uh Israel and in Lebanon and for very different reasons and it’s the same joke and they don’t even know they’re both telling it yet which is you know
There’ll be a day Neil when people will say wow you guys used bullets Why would you use bullets?
U because drones are all over the place.
And I believe that for whatever reason, because we’re pretty good with technology as a as a military-industrial complex, we’re behind on these.
We have these big ass drones that do really amazing things >> the size of airplanes.
Yeah.
>> And they’re using things off the shelf.
I mean, the the stuff that they’re firing like the Iranians use and that have become a big thing uh with Hezbollah because, you know, they get it exported from the regime, they look like u just shitty uh model planes with a couple of like weed whacker engines on it and they’re delivering a 2, three lb payload, which is plenty when it’s plastic explosive.
>> And that’s what they’re zipping all over.
And I believe we’ve been caught behind on this.
The Chinese are way ahead on it.
And a lot of the UAP stuff is a technological story.
>> I don’t see why not.
You’re right.
Because there’s there’s the natural explanations for some of them.
You know, weather balloons, uh the night sky.
Many people don’t know the night sky, what the moon can do, the sun, moon, and planets.
Then there is uh uh actual aerial craft.
>> Fighter pilots and astronauts.
Why not?
Right.
Are not known for being dopes and if they’re seeing things zipping around that freak out, why would we give it no credence?
>> Right.
No.
So that’s why I’m not giving it no credence.
That’s that’s my only point now that it’s it’s taken out of the level of the backyard farmer.
No offense to farmers, by the way.
>> I’m sure there’s some fine accurate data taking.
>> They still have the crop >> farmers out there.
>> They still got the crop surface.
>> Yeah.
No one mounts a camera to watch it happen overnight.
Why are the aliens are shy?
That’s weird.
That’s weird.
>> Well, you know, we’re not exactly the nicest people.
>> I’m just saying mount a camera >> so that we can see the alien do it.
>> Well, you’re not saying that you don’t believe in the crop circles.
>> I’m saying crop circles are real.
>> What are you saying?
>> Crop circles are real.
We’ve seen crop circles.
>> How do you think they got there?
I’m not convinced that aliens did it because they’d have to come in the dark of night and they’d have to be shy.
And do you know who has the most crop circles in the world?
Countries that don’t have food shortages.
Okay.
It’s in the book.
I have it in the book.
Okay.
I looked it up.
Okay.
Grain producing countries to countries where people are starving.
They’re not traveling their crops to make you think aliens landed.
So, plus there’s another thing.
98, no higher.
The numbers in the book, uh, very close to 100, 99% of all, so it’s not that low.
95% of all reported UFO sightings are from English-speaking countries.
>> Yes.
>> You go to another country, you want to talk about aliens, they say, “Well, I saw a movie, but why do you care?”
And meanwhile, you come to an English-speaking country.
So, Canada, United States, UK, Australia, uh, New Zealand.
The five eyes.
What do they call it?
The five.
Yeah.
>> Oh, yeah.
Right.
Right.
>> The five eyes.
That’s call that.
Uh, United States, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, UK.
The It’s called the Five Eyes.
And they dominate the world in UFO sightings.
Now, it could be because we know where to call and other countries don’t.
That’s possible.
But still, it’s hard to sweep under the rug the cultural forces operating on our imagination.
>> So, you’re going to be watching and listening to this for a long time, but the book came out today.
And I hope today >> I hope that we >> I’m in Just let the record show I’m in your studio today.
>> Yes.
Also known as my dining room.
And I just want to know that whatever happens with this book and I hope that it blows people away.
Okay?
>> It >> if it’s my biggest selling book, I will come back and kick your ass.
>> I know.
I know you will.
I know.
And you know what?
People would love to see that, too.
>> You I love and I appreciate so much.
I wish you every success.
>> Oh, thank you.
>> We never needed what you’re about more than we do right now.
>> Oh, that’s a that’s a that’s a loving sentence.
Thank you.
I’m telling you, I’m a big I’m a big fan and I’m a believer.
>> All right, >> tie aside.
>> I mean, you are really making it hard, you know.
>> Neil deGrasse Tyson, I appreciate you.
>> Thanks, dude.
>> You are a good man.
>> All right.
>> Neil deGrasse Tyson, Take Me to Your Leader is the book.
I hope it blows up.
And here’s why.
It can’t be that there’s nothing.
And I don’t mean little green men.
I mean all of these programs over all of these years and all of this money.
And if it’s all classified, didn’t they just tell us there’s something worth classifying?
To me, it’s always been about transparency.
And I love that a serious thinker like Neil deGrasse Tyson is getting involved in this very important conversation.
And as you saw, a conversation with Neil is always going to take you to a lot of places.
And the only thing they all share is they’re all deep.
Thank you for subscribing and following, checking me out in the morning on Sirius Radio, here on the podcast, and at night at NewsNation.
It’s good to be with you everywhere.
Check out the swag if you want to brand yourself as a critical thinker.
The challenges are real, so let’s get after it.
